Pretty sure you would have a much better overall "optical" experience with the Redfield. From what I have heard they are solid scopes and provide good value for what you pay. And yes you can use the Redfield for hunting/shooting under 200 yds, I would think with 4x you could hunt probably down to 25yds without to much issue. Maybe some more experienced Hunters will chime in.

A 100yrd zero seems to be the favorite around here, but as EBrown stated we don't exactly what your application is. That would be helpful.