I did have a heavy piece of paper in there per what I've read on this forum, but the ring around the edge sticks up about 0.030". I didn't look closely enough at it... it's plainly visible but I was in a hurry and it was a little dark (excuses, excuses). I can fix the bluing well enough, no big deal. I'm going to give Midway a call so they can check the rest of their stock. I might not have the only wrench like this.

EDIT: I called Midway and spoke with someone in customer service. They were thankful that I called and asked if I wanted to exchange it, apologized, etc., I said it was easier for me to fix this one rather than mess around trying to ship this one back. They gave me a $10 credit for my troubles - this is why I have been dealing with them since the early 1990's and will continue to. They also gave me an email address so I could send the photo and they could see exactly what I was talking about.