Yea I'm aware that people run their firing pin dry in the winter season and I have also seen more than 1 product comparison just like the one you're describing and there's a few products that did well and will be more than adequate for anything I do. Not about to list any specific names, not ready to open the huge can of worms that is lubrication... lol. Everyone has a prefered product and most of them will work just fine as long as you don't neglect your gun for long periods, in my opinion.