It is hard to go wrong with the regular duplex with a practical zero. I guess the question you have to ask yourself is whether or not you would benefit from a Long Range reticle? I don't hunt deer anymore, but it was highly uncommon for me to shoot a deer over 75 yards because of where I hunted. However, if you plan to shoot long distances, the holdover dots may come in handy. Otherwise, I would go with the standard duplex and set a good zero that will cover all your distances for a kill shot. I like the simplicity of that, especially if you might be shooting at something that may want to eat you.

I don't tout myself as much of a hunter, so the others here may have a better insight on things.