Received the new baffle, it helped but didn't fix it. The dimensions of the new baffle vs the original were identical, but the new baffle still had coating material on the ramp face that engages the bolt handle. Just a tiny amount of material helped with primary extraction, but I could tell even after 4-5 attempts that the coating material was getting worn away and that the problem would certainly return.

UPS picked up the complete rifle and it's on its way back to Savage so that they can have a look.

So the issue is to much gap between the baffle and bolt handle. Replacing the baffle with new didn't fix it, I'm also wondering if any of the aftermarket replacement bolt handles might help? Seems like it should work as is, and I'm hoping that Savage will do the right thing here and find a solution, but you never know.