Havent used either Bill, but I have been very involved with both portable benches and shooting tripods for a long time.
I'll; start by saying the best one dosent yet exist, as none will match the solid support a well built bench offers.
And an argument could be made regarding a good shooter using a prone position with a bipod.
Problem arises when hunting and uneven ground conditions, especially in mountainous terrain.
Other factors such as vegetation and low brush can figure in also.
All of which might have impacted your decision to consider an alternet position for shooting.
I did a Google search of the Caldwell tripods, and came up with 2 models both offered by Cabelas.
The Deadshot model @109.99, and the Magnum model @ 249.99. The major difference appears to be in the tripod quality.
If I were locked into deciding on just those two, the magnum would be my choice hands down.
No doubt both would work well for one shot, but what about follow up shots?
If your using it for varmints or just casual shooting, then the priorities wont be as high.
But for serious hunting, don't rush into this and don't let dollars make your decision.
I would also suggest you look at "the Ultimate Tripod" made by McFadden machine co in Blairsville PA.
Also the Lone Star tripod made in Texas. Both would be more expensive than the Caldwell, but pretty much top of the line.
We use both at our camp and both are very good. I have made a few of my own which also work very well, but it all starts with the tripod quality.
If your interested I can email pics.
Bookmarks