Seeing you've checked the chamber headspace and tried various ammo( head clearance, primers,etc) we'll eliminate those as the cause.
Cratering and or blanking primers is mainly do the pin tip profile and any chamfer around the pin hole. If you look at the tip on the left you'll see its ground more on a taper about a .030" or so long instead of a radius.
A pin with the factory profile on the left and one I re-ground to a radius on the right.
The pins set for .020" protrusion in the same bolthead. The factory on the left, the re-gound one on the right.
Since the primer anvil stops the pin forward travel and indents a primer no more than .025" the taper allows a gap between the pin tip and pin hole. Most times the indentation is less than .025" leaving an even larger gap.
Unfortunately, squaring the bolthead face is the only way to eliminate any chamfer around the pin hole.
As far as the inconsistent strikes it could be a number of things or a combination of them. A piece of a blanked primer cup in the bolthead, the trigger over travel set too tight, the sear contacting the stock, the sear binding on the action, too much pin protrusion(.030"-.040" is all you need) and etc. Its one of those issues you'll have to eliminate the possible problems one at a time.
In times like this the "supposedly installed by a gunsmith" worries me!
Bill
Bookmarks