Deer Bullet For 223 Savage Edge

[Willy]

Just wondering if anyone out there has done any white-tail deer hunting with a 223 caliber. I have the Edge in 223 which is a 1 in 9 twist rate and was wondering if the twist rate would stabilize a 62 to 75 grain bullet, or whether I may have to stay with a 55 gr bullet and just go for a neck shot.

[Ted_Feasel]

I'm not a hunter but my brother is a big hunter and he would be very against using something so light to hunt a deer because of the risk of it not killing it and just injuring it and making it suffer and from what I've read you should not try to put a deer down with anything less than a 75 grain because of those risks but again I'm not a hunter so just my 2 cents on what I've heard

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

[prdatr]

I have used Federal Premium with 55gr Trophy Bonded Bearclaw in 22-250 out to 200 yards on Mule Deer does, never needed a followup shot. I have a friend who has used an AR in 223 to take antelope and I believe his last one around 300 yards. I can ask what bullet he used but I think you're on the right track looking at those bullet weights.

[Ted_Feasel]

Right on, like I said I'm not a hunter so I really don't know... it actually came up with my brother one time because I have a 22-250 (way more energy than .223 or 5.56) and he and his friends said they would not want to try because they would be afraid the deer may not go down and suffer and they may have to track it for miles. My 22-250 has 24" 1/12 barrel and won't stabilize a 75gr bullet.. I have to stick with 55-62gr range.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

[prdatr]

He told me that he took two doe, one at 140 and one at 350.

[Ted_Feasel]

With a 22-250 I wouldn't doubt it... they are sending bullets up to 4300 fps... that's alot of energy... the are very flat, fast and accurate but usually the .224 rounds are more geared towards varmint sniping :)

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

[Mb1500]

First check if it is legal in your state to hunt deer with a 223. Also depends where in the country as the deer are not all the same size across the country. If legal I would wait for a clean neck shot. I've shot 62 grain fusions out of my AR 1:9 16" barrel and they seem to stabilize fine. I wouldn't be too confident in the 75grain mostly 1;7 guys shoot those.

[Willy]

I have tried the Fusion 62g ammo but my rifle doesn't seem to "like" those.
prdatr, did your friend go for heart/lung shots, or head/neck area,? What bullets was your friend using? BTW, I don't load my own ammo so I have to get what there is on the shelf.

[prdatr]

He used a 60 gr Vmax and lives in Wyoming so I would imagine a heart lung shot which is common place for most western style spot and stalk hunting. I'll ask about shot placement and I know in the southeast neck shots seem to be the norm.

[prdatr]

He got back to me and yes, heart lung shots and both times the bullet exited. Hope that helps.

[ktmracer358]

http://www.speer-bullets.com/ballistics/detail.aspx?id=14

I would like to think thies would be pretty devastating.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

[Ted_Feasel]

He got back to me and yes, heart lung shots and both times the bullet exited. Hope that helps.I think from a ballistic standpoint you don't want the bullet to exit.. you want as much, preferably all the bullets energy to be absorbed by the vital organs of the deer helping ensure it's quick demise. When a bullet exits that means all of its energy wasn't absorbed by the target and that increases the chances of it not being a humane or quick kill.. maybe look for a bullet that has a better expansion rate when it hits soft tissue. I believe the hornaday bullets are deeper penetrating before they expand. Something like the SGK may expand better.. again, not a hunter but I do really take pride in "trying" to understand ballistics. At any rate it's probably worth exploring:)

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

[sharpshooter]

The best rated bullet for that application is the Sierra 65 gr Game King.

[Ted_Feasel]

The best rated bullet for that application is the Sierra 65 gr Game King.Sounds like his rifle can probably stabilize a 65gr also

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

[JakeH]

I'd use the 62gr Fusion and either neck shots or very tight behind the shoulder.

Actually I'd use something bigger as .223 is very much marginal for deer, but that's not what you asked.

[prdatr]

I think from a ballistic standpoint you don't want the bullet to exit.. you want as much, preferably all the bullets energy to be absorbed by the vital organs of the deer helping ensure it's quick demise. When a bullet exits that means all of its energy wasn't absorbed by the target and that increases the chances of it not being a humane or quick kill.. maybe look for a bullet that has a better expansion rate when it hits soft tissue. I believe the hornaday bullets are deeper penetrating before they expand. Something like the SGK may expand better.. again, not a hunter but I do really take pride in "trying" to understand ballistics. At any rate it's probably worth exploring:)

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

Good point. I like it when the bullet exits as it creates a better blood trail.

[Willy]

I also don't mind the bullet exiting as it leaves a much better blood trail. I've shot deer through the heart with a 30-06 and it still went about 50 yards. A friend shot a deer through the heart with a 300 Win Mag and it ran 50 yards. Shoot 'em through the neck or head and they don't move more than a step.

[bowhntr62a]

He got back to me and yes, heart lung shots and both times the bullet exited. Hope that helps.

I used to live in Wyoming back in the 80s and 223 was not a legal caliber back then ! 6MM was the smallest caliber you could use !


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[prdatr]

I used to live in Wyoming back in the 80s and 223 was not a legal caliber back then ! 6MM was the smallest caliber you could use !


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

They changed it in 2013 for antelope, deer, lion and wolf.

[bowhntr62a]

They changed it in 2013 for antelope, deer, lion and wolf.

That's good to know !


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk