New in Box or almost ?

[zap]

Would you rather buy a rifle that is "new in box " never shot, or one that was shot 40-50 rounds to develop a load and show pics of groups that are 1/2 inch or better ?

[snowgetter1]

I have never had a used gun fail me yet. But, I guess it would be on your intent of use or peace of mind. There is really no way to know the like new gun only had 40-50 rounds fired or if it did did the guy shoot them as fast as he could. But, some of my best shooting barrels have been used unknown background Savage barrels. I would do whatever you are comfortable with.

[JWW123]

depends on the price

[Fotheringill]

NIB only unless it was your mother selling the rifle to you and only if you are her favorite child.

Why was the rifle sold after a load was developed for it?

You can't be 100% sure you are being told the truth. At least with a NIB, you will have nobody to blame but Savage instead of having Savage and yourself.